Possessive Pronouns
The correct British grammar account — distinguishing Possessive Adjectives from Possessive Pronouns, with full rules, examples, and explanations.
Important Grammatical Distinction in British Grammar
Traditional British grammar makes a clear distinction between Possessive Adjectives (my, your, his, her, its, our, their) and Possessive Pronouns (mine, yours, his, hers, its, ours, theirs). The former modify nouns and are therefore adjectives; only the latter truly substitute for nouns and are therefore pronouns. This is the classification followed by Nesfield, Wren & Martin, and all standard British examination syllabi.
The Correct Classification
In traditional British grammar, words expressing possession are divided into two separate word classes depending on how they function in a sentence. The key question is always: does the word stand before a noun, or does it stand alone in place of a noun?
| Person | Number | Gender | Possessive Adjective (+ noun) | Possessive Pronoun (alone) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Singular | — | my | mine |
| 2nd | Sing./Plural | — | your | yours |
| 3rd | Singular | Masculine | his | his |
| 3rd | Singular | Feminine | her | hers |
| 3rd | Singular | Neuter | its | its |
| 1st | Plural | — | our | ours |
| 3rd | Plural | — | their | theirs |
Possessive Adjectives — Full Explanation
Possessive adjectives are sometimes called pronominal adjectives in classical British grammar, because they are derived from pronouns but function as adjectives. In the tradition of Nesfield's English Grammar Past and Present and Wren & Martin's High School English Grammar — the standard texts for British-pattern grammar instruction — these are consistently classified as adjectives, not pronouns.
The Seven Possessive Adjectives
| Adjective | Person | Refers to | Example sentence |
|---|---|---|---|
| my | 1st singular | The speaker | I have finished my work. |
| your | 2nd sing./pl. | The person(s) addressed | Have you collected your ticket? |
| his | 3rd masc. sing. | A male person or animal | The barrister read his notes carefully. |
| her | 3rd fem. sing. | A female person or animal | She submitted her dissertation on time. |
| its | 3rd neuter sing. | A thing, animal, or institution | The committee published its report. |
| our | 1st plural | The speaker and others | We missed our train to Edinburgh. |
| their | 3rd plural | People or things previously named | The students revised their essays. |
Why They Are Adjectives — Explained
Three grammatical facts confirm that these words are adjectives:
- 1They modify nouns. Every possessive adjective must be attached to a noun: my opinion, your coat, his decision, their plan. Just as the adjective "large" in "large house" describes the house, "my" in "my house" qualifies the house by telling us whose it is.
- 2They cannot stand alone as subject or object. You cannot say: "My is on the table." or "She gave my the book." — both are ungrammatical. A true pronoun can stand alone as subject or object; these cannot.
- 3They answer the adjectival question "whose?" In the sentence "his report", asking "whose report?" gives the answer "his" — functioning exactly as an adjective answers a descriptive question about a noun.
Possessive Adjectives with Different Noun Types
Possessive Adjective vs. Personal Pronoun — Do Not Confuse
Possessive Pronouns — Full Explanation
The Possessive Pronouns
| Pronoun | Person | Replaces | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| mine | 1st singular | my + noun | That pen is mine. (= my pen) |
| yours | 2nd sing./pl. | your + noun | Is this bag yours? (= your bag) |
| his | 3rd masc. sing. | his + noun | The red folder is his. (= his folder) |
| hers | 3rd fem. sing. | her + noun | The achievement is hers. (= her achievement) |
| its | 3rd neuter sing. | its + noun | The decision is its. (= its decision) [rare in use] |
| ours | 1st plural | our + noun | The victory is ours. (= our victory) |
| theirs | 3rd plural | their + noun | The mistake was theirs. (= their mistake) |
Why They Are Pronouns — Explained
- 1They stand alone in place of a noun phrase. "Mine" replaces "my book/pen/idea" — the whole noun phrase. This is the defining feature of a pronoun: substituting for a noun.
- 2They perform noun functions. They can be subject ("Mine is ready"), object ("He borrowed mine"), or complement ("It is mine") — all functions of a noun, not an adjective.
- 3No noun follows them. Unlike possessive adjectives, they never precede a noun. "Mine book" or "yours report" are completely ungrammatical.
Possessive Pronouns as Subject
Possessive Pronouns as Subject Complement
This is the most frequent use — appearing after a linking verb such as is, was, are, were.
Possessive Pronouns as Object
The Contrast — Side by Side
The clearest way to see the distinction is to compare the same pair of words in two different positions. The meaning of ownership is identical; only the grammatical function differs.
| Pair | Possessive Adjective (before noun) | Possessive Pronoun (stands alone) |
|---|---|---|
| my / mine | My coat is on the chair. | The coat on the chair is mine. |
| your / yours | Have you read your letter? | Have you read yours? |
| his / his | His argument was persuasive. | The persuasive argument was his. |
| her / hers | She lost her passport. | She lost hers. |
| its / its | The firm changed its policy. | [its — same form; rarely used independently] |
| our / ours | Our train leaves at six. | The six o'clock train is ours. |
| their / theirs | Their approach was flawed. | The flawed approach was theirs. |
Grammatical Functions Compared
| Function | Possessive Adjective | Possessive Pronoun |
|---|---|---|
| Modifies a noun | ✓ Always | ✗ Never |
| Stands alone | ✗ Never | ✓ Always |
| Subject of verb | ✗ my is ready — wrong | ✓ Mine is ready. |
| Object of verb | ✗ Take my. — wrong | ✓ Take mine. |
| Subject complement | ✗ It is my. — wrong | ✓ It is mine. |
| Object of preposition | ✗ a friend of my — wrong | ✓ a friend of mine |
| Word class | Adjective | Pronoun |
its vs. it's
This is the most frequently made error involving possessive forms in English writing. The confusion arises from the general rule that apostrophe + s signals possession in nouns (the dog's lead). But that rule applies to nouns only — never to pronouns. No pronoun, whether possessive adjective or possessive pronoun, ever takes an apostrophe to show possession.
The Substitution Test — Always Reliable
Replace the word with "it is" or "it has". If the sentence still makes grammatical sense, use it's. If it does not make sense, use its.
whose vs. who's
The same principle applies to this pair. Whose is the possessive form of who — functioning as either a possessive adjective (before a noun) or a possessive pronoun (standing alone). Who's is a contraction of who is or who has.
Key Rules — British Grammar
- ADJ 1my, your, his, her, its, our, their are Possessive Adjectives. They must always be followed by a noun. They modify the noun by indicating ownership. They cannot function as subjects, objects, or complements on their own.
- PRO 1mine, yours, his, hers, its, ours, theirs are Possessive Pronouns. They always stand alone — no noun follows. They replace a full noun phrase and can be the subject, object, or complement of a sentence.
- GEN 1No possessive form — adjective or pronoun — ever takes an apostrophe. Not *my's, *your's, *her's, *their's, *it's (as possessive). The apostrophe in it's marks a contraction, not possession.
- GEN 2Pronoun agreement: Both possessive adjectives and possessive pronouns agree with the owner, not the thing owned. "The teacher marked her papers" — her refers to the teacher (owner), not to the papers.
- GEN 3his and its are the same form for both the adjective and the pronoun. All other pairs differ in form: my/mine, your/yours, her/hers, our/ours, their/theirs.
- GEN 4The double genitive — of + possessive pronoun — is correct British English: "a friend of mine, a colleague of hers, a habit of his, a weakness of theirs."
- GEN 5Before a gerund (verbal noun), use the possessive adjective: "We appreciated your attending the meeting" — not "you attending". This is formal British usage.
Common Errors — Identified & Corrected
| Error Type | Incorrect Form | Correct Form | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apostrophe on possessive adjective | The dog wagged it's tail. | The dog wagged its tail. | its = possessive adjective; no apostrophe |
| Possessive adjective used alone | That pen is my. | That pen is mine. | Without a following noun, use the possessive pronoun |
| Possessive pronoun before noun | I finished mine work. | I finished my work. | Before a noun, use the possessive adjective |
| Apostrophe on possessive pronoun | The mistake was their's. | The mistake was theirs. | Possessive pronouns never take an apostrophe |
| Non-existent form her's | The red pen is her's. | The red pen is hers. | her's does not exist; correct form is hers |
| Confusion: its (adj.) vs. it's (contr.) | Its been a long session. | It's been a long session. | Contraction of "it has" needs apostrophe → it's |
| Confusion: whose vs. who's | The MP who's bill was rejected... | The MP whose bill was rejected... | Possessive needed; who's = who is/has |
| Pronoun agrees with thing, not owner | The teacher corrected their essay. [meaning the teacher's own essay] | The teacher corrected her essay. | Adjective must agree with the owner (teacher = singular feminine) |
| Wrong apostrophe on your's | The choice is your's. | The choice is yours. | your's does not exist; possessive pronoun is yours |
| Using "you" instead of "your" before gerund | We appreciated you helping us. [formal writing] | We appreciated your helping us. | In formal British English, possessive adjective precedes a gerund |
Self-Test —
Identify the correct form and state whether it is a possessive adjective or possessive pronoun.
Comments
Post a Comment